Wednesday, January 18, 2017

Broken Date by R. L. Stine

**This blog contains adult language.**

Warning: Contains Spoilers!!  This is a recap blog which means I read the book and tell you everything that happens so you don't have to read it yourself.  Do NOT continue to read unless you want to know who the bad guy/girl/redneck cliche is.

Tag Line: Does her boyfriend really want to kill her?  (Okay, that is a lame tag line.)

From the Back of the Book: A date with death.  Jamie and Tom are in love.  They've gone steady since junior high and are planning to graduate high school and attend college together.  Then, of course, they'll marry.  Everything's perfect until Tom breaks a date - and all the horror begins.  Suddenly her perfectly planned dream has become a nightmare.  She must talk to him.  But what has happened to Tom?  To Jamie's horror, the boy she loves is stalking her, calling her, threatening her.  Tom can't afford to let her live.  And there's nowhere she can hide.

Validity Confession:  This isn't Point Horror.  I feel like we don't even care anymore.  I'm going to change the description of this blog because we're not only about Point Horror here anymore.  I'm still going to pretend the characters are in PH land though.  Old habits die hard.

This book was published in 1988 which makes it one of the earlier ones I've recapped.  I hadn't read it before this.  Believe me, if I had, I wouldn't have voluntarily picked this off the shelf.  Yes, folks, I picked this one.  I was terrified my manager would bring me an Athkins or a Cooney so I voluntarily grabbed a Stine.  I usually find him comforting in his awfulness.  Usually.

We begin with our protagonist Jamie getting a paper cut. She's mad at the magazine that cut her. She's mad at her hair which she'd like to cut short but can't because her boyfriend wants it long. 

Mercy. I'm on my third sentence of this recap and I'm about to go full-on rage rant. It's too early in the book for this, y'all. I'm going to try to breathe and just cool the boil.

Oh, fuck it.

Girls, listen to me and listen good. YOUR BODY DOES NOT BELONG TO YOUR SIGNIFICANT OTHER. It is YOUR body. You and YOU ALONE make decisions about what happens to it. If you want to cut your hair, cut it. If you want to grow the hair on your legs out until it can be braided, do it. If you want to pierce or ink or decorate or shave ANY part of your body, do it. YOUR SIGNIFICANT OTHER DOES NOT OWN ANY PIECE OF YOUR BODY. If he likes your hair long and you want it short just tell him to get the fuck over it. If he really loves you then he won't care if every hair on your head falls out. If he tells you he doesn't love you any more because you won't conform to his idea of beauty, then he's done you a huge fucking favor because you don't want that asshole in your life anyway.

And I'm stepping off my soap box now...

To review, Jamie's pissed about the paper cut, her hair and the fact that the asshole....I mean her boyfriend Tom is an hour late for their date. It's out of character for him and she's worried. She keeps checking her Swatch watch (oh the nostalgia....and the jealousy....I never had one) and tripping over things because she's adorbs clumsy. Her brother Casey comes in to ask her to play Hungry Hippos with him and she screams at him like a shrew. This is so shocking. Stine is writing an unlikable protagonist? This has never happened before and I am not sure how to handle it. I feel the vapors coming on. I shall retire to my fainting couch and call for my smelling salts to be brought to me on a little silver tray by my lady's maid.

I might be a tad too sarcastic today. Might.

Jamie isn't worried he's seeing another girl. They've been going together since junior high and she's secure in the relationship. They're going to go to college together and then get married and live a bland little life. She calls her best friend Ann-Marie to whine. I almost didn't {bold} Ann-Marie's name because she's described as having a “round face” and we all know we don't need to pay attention to the fat girls in PH (ish). They're all written as giant losers who only impact the story if they turn out to be the bad guy (and it's usually because they hate the protagonist for being skinny and beautiful because in PH (ish) land you can't be beautiful and fat). Ann-Marie lives up to the stereotype by making jokes out of everything Jamie says until Jamie gets pissed and snaps at her.

Sigh.

Finally Ann-Marie asks Jamie if she wants to go to the mall to kill some time before the dance that night. Jamie reluctantly agrees because it's too late to go ice skating even if Tom ever does show up. It's too late for ice skating but there's plenty of time to go to the mall? Ooookay. The girls are in the mall 20 minutes later and it's packed. Ann-Marie really wants to buy a pair of neon pink Reeboks (nostalgia overload in this book) but Jamie disdainfully doesn't want to be anywhere near the atrocious shoes. She decides to go down to the Record Rack (records!) instead. On her way, she passes the Diamond Ranch and sees some antique stick-pins in the window that are on sale. She decides to go in and check them out.

The door closes behind her and silence washes over her. The place is completely empty. She walks through the store and then suddenly sees a robbery happening toward the back. The robber has a distinctive shock of white-blonde hair over his forehead and she recognizes him as Tom.

Okay.

There's so much wrong with that paragraph, y'all.

First, the fact that the shop has a door is weird. I assumed it was an indoor mall and stores in that kind of mall rarely have doors that are closed during operating hours. It's not unheard of so I'm giving this one a pass, but it's rare so it gets a mention. Second, the mall is described as packed. Jamie and Ann-Marie were literally pushing through people just a minute before. So even if the place DOES inexplicably have a door, who the hell would rob a place in broad daylight just feet from where packs and packs of people are walking by? And third, who the hell commits a crime in broad daylight where any number of witnesses could happen upon him and doesn't disguise the ONE THING that makes him easily identifiable?

REALLY, STINE????

Jamie stays hidden behind some display cases and watches as the robber demands money from the register. The clerk repeatedly calls the robber a punk which seems rather unwise when being held at gunpoint. Finally the robber shoots the clerk and Jamie makes a run for it. She hopes he doesn't see and recognize her on the way out. She slips and falls before she makes it very far and then Ann-Marie is there helping her up.

Jamie tells Ann-Marie what she witnessed. At first Ann-Marie doesn't seem to react. Then they see security guards running into the Diamond Ranch. Ann-Marie tells her that she needs to talk to the police but Jamie just wants to go home. In the car, she lets it slip that Tom was the robber and Ann-Marie thinks she's in shock or something. She doesn't believe that Tom could possibly do such a thing. She points out that Jamie isn't wearing her glasses and maybe she wasn't seeing clearly enough to identify anyone. Jamie points out that she doesn't need to see clearly to identify the boy she's been dating forever. Ann-Marie admits that all Jamie would need to see is the white piece of hair in his bangs to identify Tom.  You know, because no one else in the world could possibly have light colored bangs.

It's so unbelievably obvious that it's NOT Tom at this point that I don't even feel like I need to read any more of the book.

Like my manager would let me get away with that.

Jamie gets home to an empty house.  Her parents are probably in Europe.  There's a message on the machine from Tom saying that the swim coach kept them super late that day and that's why he didn't show up for skating. He tells her he has something to do before he picks her up from the dance and he'll see her later. Jamie thinks he sounds nervous and wonders if he called her before the robbery or after. She seems particularly hung up on this point.  Because it matters, y'all.  It DOES.

Jamie debates whether she should go to the dance with him and then decides she owes it to him to let him explain what happened. Then she'll break up with him.

Sigh.

She heads to her room to start getting ready and remembers that she put the tickets for the dance in her wallet. When she searches her purse, her wallet is missing. The chapter ends as she wonders if she dropped her wallet in the Diamond Ranch.

Tom comes to pick her up that evening and she's filled with dread. Of course she is. She thinks she witnessed him kill a man. You'd think this would be enough for her to break up with him and refuse to see him and....oh, I don't know....call the POLICE...but this is a Point Horror (ish) so she's resigned herself to dating a murderer. Allegedly. She notes he's wearing a new sweater and he seems super upbeat. He comments that he likes her shirt and she snaps at him that it's a blouse not a shirt. Holy hell, Stine, no teenager uses the word blouse. Ever.

They walk to the dance since Tom doesn't own a car. He jokes the whole time and Jamie thinks he's being silly and nervous. It irritates her that he could kid around like this when he just murdered someone that afternoon. They see a couple of classmates (Sherry and Alex) up ahead and join them. Jamie hangs back a bit as the other three laugh and joke around all the way to the school. When they get to the doors, Jamie suddenly remembers that she doesn't have tickets. She tells the teacher at the door that she lost her wallet and he waves them in anyway. Either he just doesn't care or Jamie is an exemplary student whom he trusts implicitly. Tom is curious about her missing wallet and Jamie wonders nervously if he picked it up at the scene of the crime.

She should be more worried that the police found it and suspect her of murder.

I guess Stine didn't realize that would be the most logical scenario here.

Tom and Jamie walk around the dance talking to friends for awhile and then they try to dance. The song is described as Disco Rap (whatever the fuck that is) and it has an awkward beat and repetitive lyrics. Finally they give up and Tom tells her that he needs to talk to her in private. He leads her to the wood shop and then starts pacing around, playing with some kind of tool. Jamie calls it a “pick” and says it has a blade. She thinks his face looks evil and angry and she starts screaming “no” at him which puzzles him immensely.

Then because it's Stine and the chapter is ending, it tells us that Jamie grabs the pick from him and stabs him right in the chest. She runs from the room screaming “I killed him. I killed him.”

The next chapter picks up with Ann-Marie finding Jamie hysterical in the hall. Tom comes out of the wood shop completely unharmed because of course he does. Jamie imagined the entire stabbing because of course she did. I hate this book because of course I do.

Sigh.

Ann-Marie treats Tom coldly and tells him that she'll be taking Jamie home now. Tom protests that he can take care of Jamie and Jamie hears it as a sinister threat. Ann-Marie is generally bitchy to him and finally leads Jamie away from the hall. She asks if Tom admitted to the robbery and Jamie says it never came up. Jamie is shivering and Ann-Marie takes off her jacket to give to her friend. Stine tells us the jacket was too SMALL so it slid off immediately. Huh. The jacket the fat girl is wearing is too small for the skinny girl. Wouldn't that mean that the skinny girl is bigger than the fat girl? I'm so confused, Stine. Get it straight.

As they approach the gym, Ann-Marie's date Buddy calls out to her that they're playing their song. It turns out their song is a Beastie Boys number. So romantic. Ann-Marie says she'll get the keys from Buddy and drive Jamie home. They can talk on the way. Jamie is happy and relieved until she sees that Buddy is upset by this turn of events. When Ann-Marie returns, Jamie tells her that she just wants to walk home by herself and think.

Stine.

You just told us that Jamie was so frightened that she hallucinated stabbing someone and then ran out into a hallway screaming. Do you expect us to buy that this SAME person is going to walk home in the dark alone? I beg you.....MAKE SENSE. Just once.  Please.

Naturally by the end of the chapter she realizes she's being followed. I'm shocked. Shocked I say! She turns and catches a glimpse of the white hair and knows it's Tom. She's scared but yells out at him, asking him if he wants to talk. He runs off and she goes into her house.

You know, I'm going to be seriously annoyed if Tom is the bad guy. Just sayin'.

Jamie's mom makes a huge fuss over her.  I guess she's not in Europe after all.  Stine really hammers hard on the fact that Jamie's mom is overweight. The word “pudgy” keeps getting thrown about. I mostly hate him. Jamie thinks her mom is like a bee, always buzzing around and getting into her personal space and irritating her. Usually this would just be teenager assholishness but Jamie's mom IS annoying. I completely lost count of how many times she told Jamie how green she was. I suppose my manager can relate because I'm always telling her she looks “wan”.

Jamie heads off to bed but she can't sleep. She decides to call Tom....because....reasons I guess. I don't know and I just read it. This book is sure making a lasting impression on me. No one answers the phone and Jamie is instantly suspicious because Tom's mom should be home. She doesn't come right out and say that Tom killed his mom but it's pretty clear that her mind is wandering down that path. As soon as she hangs up, the phone rings because in PH (ish) land the bad guy always calls the protagonist. Sure enough a voice tells her that he's very sorry she saw him at the mall that afternoon. At least he's a polite obscene caller.

Jamie calls the person Tom and tells him that he can talk to her about this. She's a great listener. The person (with a muffled and slow voice) just keeps repeating that she's given him no choice and then he hangs up.

Jamie frets for awhile and then decides to call Tom's friend (and fellow swim team member) Andy. She asks him if Tom was at swim practice and Andy confirms that he was. However, Andy didn't see him in the locker room after and assumed that Tom left early. Jamie realizes that Tom probably had time to get to the mall and commit the crime and she “oh noes” herself until the end of the chapter.

That night she has a typical PH (ish) nightmare about Tom showing up and trying to kill her. The next morning she goes downstairs and her mom tells her that Tom stopped by and left a gift. The gift turns out to be a pair of gold earrings and Jamie is horrified that he bought them with the money he stole from the man. She sees a story in the newspaper about the robbery/murder and it makes her more frightened.

Ann-Marie comes to pick her up so they can go swimming at the Y. No one else is in the pool. They swim for awhile and then Ann-Marie conveniently remembers that she was supposed to call her aunt about babysitting. She leaves Jamie alone.

Hmmmm. I wonder if anything will happen while Jamie is alone in the pool???

Jamie floats for awhile. She imagines confronting Tom about the robbery and Tom reassuring her that he was no where near the mall and everything being fine. As she floats she notices a shadow fall across the water. Someone is standing on the balcony above the pool staring down at her. Despite the fact that she is, again, not wearing her glasses, Jamie can tell it's a boy and he has blonde hair. She hears him laugh softly and thinks the sound is super menacing.

Ann-Marie returns as Jamie is running across the tile floor like an idiot. I'm surprised she didn't fall and bust her skull. Jamie tells her that they have to leave and, at first, Ann-Marie is skeptical again. Jamie worries that she's “cracking up”.

Ann-Marie encourages Jamie to talk to Tom and Jamie decides that she should. She's going to take the bus to his house since Ann-Marie has to leave to babysit for her aunt. Jamie walks to the bus stop and again she hears footsteps following her. This is getting super boring, y'all. She reaches the bus stop as the chapter ends, so hands reach out and grab her. Fortunately for her, the bus arrives at that instant and she's able to pull away and get into the bus.

The bus driver doesn't see who it was because he was adjusting the mirrors. When Jamie looks out at the sidewalk, there's no one there. She rides the bus to the stop nearest Tom's house and then disembarks. When she gets to Tom's house, a strange man answers. He's in his mid-20's but already balding. He says his name is Eric and he's a co-worker of Tom's dad. He had stopped by to get some paperwork that morning when a call came in saying Tom's dad had been in a horrible accident and was in critical condition. Tom and his mother had left immediately and Eric had stayed behind to take care of the cat and close up the house.

Only, it says that Tom and his mom let at 9:30 which Jamie tells us means that Tom couldn't have been the person at the pool or by the bus. That means 9:30 must have been awhile ago. So why is this Eric guy still in the house? He should be long gone by then. Something doesn't add up about this.

Eric tells Jamie that Tom left an envelope for her. Except Tom had no idea that she was even coming to his house and they expected Eric to be leaving just a few minutes after they did. So why would Tom leave anything for Jamie with Eric?

You stopped making sense a long time ago, Stine. I'm expecting the piranhas to show up any minute now.

Jamie takes the envelope and imagines what is written inside. She imagines that Tom tells her that it wasn't him in the jewelry shop the day before and that the earrings had belonged to his grandma and on and on for three or four paragraphs. She spends an awful long amount of time crafting this fake letter in her head. She walks back to the bus stop and then finally decides to read the letter.

But before she can, a dog runs up and grabs it from her.

You have no idea how much I wish I wasn't serious right now. It's actually in the book. A dog stole her letter.

For fuck's sake, Stine.

Jamie chases the dog all around and finally gets him to drop it. The letter is short.

Dear Jamie – I guess we all act crazy sometimes. I'll try to call you. Love, Tom.”

She's disappointed it doesn't match her fantasy letter.

Time passes. She's playing Scrabble with her little brother. She ends up yelling at him and yelling at her mother and just generally being a huge brat. Her aunt calls to talk to her mother and Jamie is furious because she wants to keep the line free for Tom to call. Several times she picks up the extension and, when she hears her aunt and mom still talking, she slams the receiver down to make the point they should be clearing the line for her.

I'm a pretty easy-going mom but I wouldn't tolerate this level of disrespect at all. At a minimum, this brat needs to lose her phone privileges.

The line finally gets clear and Ann-Marie calls to find out if Tom has called. Jamie laments that he has not. They hang up and Jamie goes to bed. The chapter is ending, so we get treated to a three page nightmare of Tom crawling through Jamie's window, confessing to the crime and then trying to kill her. The nightmare only ends because the phone rings. The voice on the other end tells her that she shouldn't have seen what she did in the mall and now she has to pay.

Like maybe he'll stand on a balcony and laugh at her again. That was truly vicious.

The next day, Ann-Marie urges Jamie to go to the police. Jamie says she will after school and Ann-Marie volunteers to go with her. The school day passes in a haze for Jamie. Several times she gets caught not paying attention. Once she's called on in math but can't answer the question because she's left her glasses at home and she can't see the board. She looks around the room and enjoys the blurriness of her eye impairment for awhile.

Jeez, y'all, do you think Stine is trying to tell us something important here? I mean, it's not like this section has BIG FUCKING CLUE written above it in neon lights or anything. I don't think we're supposed to notice that Jamie can't see crap without her glasses and we're not supposed to remember she wasn't wearing them the day of the robbery and we're not supposed to question how she ONLY identified “Tom” at a distance by his blonde hair or anything. Just ignore the BIG FUCKING CLUE sign, y'all. It means nothing.

The school day ends and Ann-Marie meets Jamie at her locker so they can go to the police station. Jamie is snappy and ungrateful for a change {sarcasm}and whines about how much her life is going to suck once she does this. They leave the building and Jamie spots Tom across the street leaning up against a van she doesn't recognize. She is so happy to see him that she yells his name and starts across the street. Ann-Marie asks her what the heck she's doing just as Jamie realizes a second Tom is running down the sidewalk toward her.

She keeps heading toward van “Tom” and he ends up grabbing her and forcing her into the back of the van. Too late she realizes that this “Tom” isn't Tom and he is, in fact, the bad guy who robbed the store, killed the man and has been making threatening phone calls to Jamie.

Jamie can't escape the van. The bad guy....who I shall call Faux Tom until I get his name....pulls onto the freeway, threatening Jamie the entire way. Stine decides to be a total dick and he gives the bad guy a very pronounced stutter. He also keeps calling her “Babes” which is Stine's standard bad guy nickname for our protagonists (it was used in the Babysitter books and maybe some others).

The bad guy's name is Okie Farnum.

Jamie feels all kinds of heinous for suspecting poor Tom. I feel a little bad because I suspected poor Ann-Marie. Sorry, Ann-Marie, but that's what you get for being in a Point Horror (ish) book.

They stop by a cabin in the woods and Okie takes Jamie out of the back of the van. They start toward the cabin when all of a sudden, Tom leaps from the roof of the van and tackles Okie.

For fuck's sake, Stine.

Seriously.

NO!!

No, Tom did not manage to ride on the top of a van at fucking freeway speeds. No he did not manage to ride on the top of the van while Okie was swerving all around. No. Just no. This is not even possible.

NO!!

Tom encourages Jamie to run and get help but Jamie is generally incompetent. She can't decide which direction to run and she just sort of spins in place uselessly for a long time. Eventually she heads into the woods but she's stopped by a woman with “bleached red hair” who turns out to be Okie's girlfriend Dolly.

First of all, what is bleached red hair? Bleached is usually white or blonde. Does he mean light red? Like strawberry blonde? Whatever.

The next chapter opens with Jamie and Tom tied up together in the cabin. Okie tells Dolly that he's going to have to drown them both in the tub and then he and Dolly will clear out of town. Dolly agrees that it has to be that way. They pick Tom first. Okie holds him under the water for exactly three minutes and then declares the deed done.

I'm sure Stine's going to tell us that Tom survived because he's a swimmer and knows how to hold his breath. I'm so over this book. Why isn't it over?

Okie thinks Jamie is pretty and he proposes keeping her as a “slave”. Dolly is pretty pissed at the idea. She knows what he really wants to keep Jamie for and she doesn't like it one bit. Okie finally decides to drown Jamie as well, but before he can, Tom comes up behind him and hits him with a broom in the shoulder hard enough to break it.

There's this huge physical struggle that I can't be bothered caring about with all four of them fighting for survival. In the end, Dolly and Okie are both knocked unconscious. Tom and Jamie decide this is the perfect opportunity to make out for awhile because it's not like there's two dangerous criminals on the floor who want to kill them or anything. Okie starts to come out of it and Tom finally remembers they're in danger. They tie up the criminals and then Tom asks her for the story.

Jamie hems and haws a great deal while Tom encourages her with gentle words and kisses on the cheek.

This is so fucking dumb.

She tells him about the robbery as they leave the cabin in Okie's van. He laughs at her for thinking it was him. If this was real life, he'd be pretty hurt and angry that she thought he was capable of robbing a store and killing a man. Stine doesn't exactly give any fucks about realism though. Jamie asks him why he's been acting so weird and he tells her that he decided to quit the swim team to get a job so he can help out his family financially. He thought she'd be disappointed in him so he was acting strange.  Does Jamie really care about him being on the swim team that much?  Is she living vicariously through his 200m relay or what?

In the end, she agrees not to go out without her glasses again and he agrees never to break another date.

The End.


Final Thoughts: This book was so stupid I can barely even muster the strength to do final thoughts. This was Stine at his worst. It was ridiculous and didn't make sense most of the time. The sad thing is that he's completely capable of writing good books. His Fear Street books were better than this. Weren't they? Am I completely misremembering my entire adolescence? I'm almost afraid to reread one and find out.  I will say that I thought the "horror" of this book was pretty lame.  Okie laughed at her once, followed her a couple of times and called her twice.  It was pretty low on the scares and lacked a lot of tension.  On the flip side, her parents weren't in Europe.  So I guess it had that going for it.

No comments:

Post a Comment